You are here:  Home >> Your turn archive >> My scoring system
My scoring system
16 Jan 2006 by JR
Tim James, www.grape.co.za , South Africa: It is often unclear to me whether tasters who use and publish scores (including myself!) claim to judge by a universal standard, or make adjustments according to the category of wine they are tasting. Can a beaujolais ever score 19 or 20? Is the first-growth bordeaux scoring 17 a 'worse' wine than the New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc with 18? My impression generally is that professionals' scoring is often adjusted (usually only slightly) to the perceived status of what is tasted: that is, one might have higher expectations of a tasting of classed...

Sorry, this page is available only to current Purple Pages members. If you're not a member, why not join today and meet a lively community of fellow wine enthusiasts?

If you are already a Purple Pager, please log in.

Sign up for Purple Pages
  • 10649 articles (two new most days) and 99325 tasting notes
  • Exclusive online access to The Oxford Companion to Wine
  • Exclusive online access to all the World Atlas of Wine maps
  • Lively and intelligent Members' forum
  • Completely independent news, comment and inside tips
Join now
£6.99 a month or £69 a year
(Available in GBP, USD, EUR or AUD)
Contact us | Team Jancis | Site FAQs | Join now | Terms and Conditions | Privacy policy | Site map | RSS
© Copyright 2000-2014 Jancis Robinson