Volcanic Wine Awards | The Jancis Robinson Story | Mission Blind Tasting

Burgundy 2012 – a difficult birth

• 5 min read
Image

Wirrten by Aubert de Villaine. See also Hanson on the Hospices' beautiful babies.

Some vintages have an easy birth: the winemaker intervenes calmly and infrequently, like the crew of a sailing boat in calm weather. But it is not uncommon for the journey towards the birth of a vintage to be more like a war, a struggle at all times to keep the boat afloat and reach the goal without too much damage!

This was the case in 2012, which will always be a unique vintage – but which one isn't – and one which will long be remembered by those who were fighting on the front line against nature's best 'soldiers' – downy and powdery mildew.

March, however, was very dry and almost summery (22 °C on average). This provoked an even earlier budburst than in 2007, the benchmark for precocity. We thought we would be harvesting in August! But what we remember most from this atypical month were the thunderstorms on 26 March, highly unusual for the time of year but a foreshadowing of what the gods had prepared for Nicolas Jacob, our vineyard manager, and his team.

From April onwards, the change was radical: cold (-2 °C on 13 April) and humidity settled in. As a result, it was impossible to get into the vineyard to plough and the grass grew wildly, encouraged and sustained by the rain. For the same reasons, we had great difficulty treating the vines: we had to be ready for any window of dry weather in order to give the plants the protection they needed. Despite constant vigilance, downy mildew appeared and attacked the vines forcefully, eliminating a percentage of the crop which is difficult to assess but significant. Powdery mildew, too, found favourable conditions. And hail joined in the attack, hitting all of the Côte de Beaune, including our Montrachet, on 30 June.

Flowering began about 9 June, but it was drawn out over a month due to persistently cold conditions. This led to significant coulure.

Here's the balance sheet of the three months during which it rained one day in three:
  • a crop already reduced by coulure and downy mildew which may well be heterogeneous at harvest due to the drawn-out flowering period 
  • but at the same time, coulure produced an interesting amount of millerandage, which always contributes to quality 
  • vigorous and healthy vines 
  • another positive: after an early sprint, vegetation growth slowed, allowing us to carry out manual work, such as disbudding, efficiently and without haste 
  • and, of course, the exceptionally early year became more or less normal, the time of flowering pointing to a late-September harvest.
At the end of June came the last 'eccentric' episode of the spring: a few days' heatwave burnt the young berries that were most exposed to the sun, further decreasing the yield and making it likely we would need to do an extra sort during harvest to drop the sunburnt berries.

In July, nature finally calmed down. We have suffered losses, but the enemy has 'retreated'. Thanks to these milder conditions, we can plough effectively, in some cases making three passes through the vines to rid them of invasive weeds. We carried out the last precautionary treatments in early August ... and it only remained for us to rely on the weather being at last closer to the season's norm.

This is what actually happened ...

August was hot and sunny with a heatwave and storms around 15 August. Each time, despite the wind often blowing towards the south, dry weather returned. The vine, having been well watered by the earlier rains, fed grapes generously, photosynthesis was promoted and sugar production progressed very rapidly. On the eve of harvest we had:
  • small clusters of grapes with very thick skins and a high percentage of berries affected by millerandage 
  • sunburn on a significant number of bunches on the sun-exposed side of the vine as a result of the heatwaves, particularly the one in June 
  • on some clusters, one or two berries that never went through veraison, ie remained green, which will be rejected during sorting 
  • no botrytis. 
In short, a very healthy harvest that could wait for full maturity. This is what we did, taking the risk of going well beyond the hundred days that normally separates harvest from mid-flowering when we decided on the harvest date.

We finally started harvesting the Corton fruit and some young vines in Vosne-Romanée with a smaller team on Friday 21 September and we started the 'big' harvest in Vosne-Romanée on Monday 24 September. The weather unfortunately deteriorated from Tuesday, and on Wednesday 26th it rained all day! We of course stopped harvesting completely that day and were very anxious because we feared strong botrytis attacks the next day.

But two factors combined to preserve the grapes effectively: on the one hand, the exceptionally thick and resistant berry skins and, on the other, cold weather, extremely cold for the season, did not allow botrytis to develop. The harvest remained exceptionally healthy. As every year, we still made a selection of the grapes as we picked – to drop the berries that were burnt and those that had not changed colour at veraison. This meant that sorting at the table was minimal and the sorting team saw a crop that was one of the healthiest in recent years. Since the weather remained cool, the fruit came in at an excellent temperature, around 15 °C, which allowed a few days' maceration before fermentation started slowly and gradually.

Fermentation has now lasted for nearly three weeks under the loving watch of Bernard Noblet and his vinification team. The first wines have been drawn off, notably that from Romanée-Conti, which was ripe first and therefore harvested first. The wines are very promising with beautiful colour and fresh, delicate aromas.

A separate chapter needs to be inserted here about Montrachet, which, like the entire Côte de Beaune, was hit by hail twice during the summer. These grapes suffered particularly badly. We harvested on Friday 28 September, ie before the end of the red harvest. This was a crop damaged by hail, botrytis and powdery mildew and needed severe sorting, resulting in a very small harvest, the smallest in recent years. We expect excellent quality but the yield will be less than half the norm.

For red wines, the yields are around 20 hl/ha, which is about 25% below normal. The average yields in 2009, for example, were 30 hl/ha.

A harvest like the one we have just completed makes us even more aware, if that were necessary, of the importance of gambling – and luck – in the success or failure of a vintage. To repeat what I said last year, it is essential to wait until the grapes reach full maturity. This year, with a perfectly healthy harvest, it was easier than last year, when botrytis was significant. But in both cases, it was necessary to wait for complete maturity, and we were lucky that the weather conditions became our ally, keeping it cool enough for the grapes to get through the heavy rain of Wednesday 26 September without being attacked by botrytis.

Crop losses due to consecutive attacks of downy mildew and sunburn on some bunches were certainly significant, but this reduction in quantity also contributed to quality since it led to a natural thinning which reduced the yield and allowed the healthy grapes to ripen better. It is quite possible that we would not have reached such maturity and quality had there been no losses.

Harvest dates:
  • Corton: 21 September 
  • Romanée-Conti: 22 September 
  • Grands Échezeaux: 22, 24 and 25 September 
  • La Tâche: 25 and 27 September 
  • Richebourg: 27 and 28 September 
  • Montrachet: 28 September 
  • Romanée-St-Vivant: 28 and 29 September 
  • Échezeaux: 29 and 30 September

Choose your plan
Member
$135
/year
Save over 15% annually
Ideal for wine enthusiasts
  • Access 294,756 wine reviews & 16,080 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
Inner Circle
$249
/year
 
Ideal for collectors
  • Access 294,756 wine reviews & 16,080 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
Professional
$299
/year
For individual wine professionals
  • Access 294,756 wine reviews & 16,080 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 25 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Business
$399
/year
For companies in the wine trade
  • Access 294,756 wine reviews & 16,080 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 250 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Pay with
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Join our newsletter

Get the latest from Jancis and her team of leading wine experts.

By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

More Free for all

Thomas Walk Vineyard in Kinsale
Free for all Jancis is put in her place, by the hybrid grapes of the Emerald Isle. A shorter version of this article...
Ungrafted monastrell vines in Jumilla
Free for all 4 June 2026 In advance of the 2026 Old Vine Conference on 8 June, we’re republishing this overview of our...
Institute of Masters of Wine logo
Free for all Alors que notre Sam Cole-Johnson et 216 autres candidats s'apprêtent à passer les examens MW la semaine prochaine, nous revenons...
The Bull interior
Free for all Great wine and pie in the Shires. Charlbury is pretty much the first stony outcrop of the Cotswolds that you...

More from JancisRobinson.com

Pine Ridge Chenin Blanc-Viognier bottle and glass of wine outdoors, on table with books
Wines of the week A summer-ready, silky white wine that’s widely available from just $8.99, £20.90 . The sleeper hit of Napa winery Pine...
Split Rail vineyard
Tasting articles Part 4 of an exploration of California’s westernmost vineyards. Above, the Split Rail vineyard in Corralitos (credit: John Benedetti)...
Fernando Mora MW and Mario López of Bodegas Frontonio
Tasting articles A close look at three of Zaragoza’s most important projects. Above, Fernando Mora MW (left) and Mario López of Bodegas...
Acered vineyard
Tasting articles To celebrate Aragón’s new map in the upcoming World Atlas of Wine , Ferran explores the wines of Zaragoza. Above...
Alexandre Delétraz's (Cave des Amandiers) vineyards in Valais @ Leif Carlsson
Tasting articles Red, white, young, old – there’s no shortage of diversity or deliciousness available in Swiss wines. You just need to...
Mt Ararat overlooking vineyards
Tasting articles Reasons to drink more Riesling; best buys; and far-flung finds – highlights from a month of tastings. Above, Mount Ararat...
Dar Sinclair, Tangier
Don't quote me Foreign parts feature heavily this month but that’s far from all. The villa pictured above overlooks Tangier. I hope you...
Sally Abé of Teal
Nick on restaurants An exciting new addition to the East London restaurant scene. Above, Sally Abé. Everything is on the small side at...
Wine inspiration delivered directly to your inbox, weekly
Our weekly newsletter is free for all
By subscribing you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.