Volcanic Wine Awards | The Jancis Robinson Story | Mission Blind Tasting

Naughty French

• 1 min read
Image

See the resulting thread in members' forum.

You know how European wine producers and non Europeans have always fought for the moral high ground? 

Europeans accuse New World winemakers of confecting their wines by adding acid and water (in the form of irrigation) whereas their own wines are oh-so-natural because they depend solely on God's irrigation (rain) and, until recently when global warming began to make its presence felt, European wine producers were never allowed to add acid. 

Well, relatively recently European laws have been changed to allow  producers in Europe to add acid, just so long as they don't add both acid and sugar to the same lot of wine, which is easy to fiddle, as one Burgundian vigneron pointed out to me, by simply adding acid to half of a lot of wine and sugar to the other.  So much for the moral high ground.

And now that European summers seem to be getting hotter and drier (see South of France swelters, for example), irrigation is becoming more and more common in Europe. In places such as Spain, Austria, even Germany now, at least growers go to the trouble of getting the rules changed to allow it, and generally use very sparing amounts of water via careful drip-irrigation systems. 

overheadirrigation

But in the Languedoc, where the somewhat tenebrous picture above was taken last week, some farmers in the lower, flatter, most ordinary vineyards have always simply turned the tap on when they think they can increase the volume of their crop and therefore bank balance.

In a world that is becoming increasingly short of water, it seems pretty crazy to irrigate by overhead spray to me. It was explained to me when I expressed surprise at how common overhead irrigation is in the Okanagan Valley in western Canada that this system has the great advantage of helping them stave off frost damage in cold weather. I can understand that. But what possible justification there can be to spray vast amounts of precious water into the air, as above, in temperatures in the 30s C/90s F when much of it must evaporate and be wasted eludes me.  Frost is not a problem in the Languedoc!

Wählen Sie Ihre Mitgliedschaft
Mitglied
$135
/Jahr
Über 15 % jährlich sparen
Ideal für Weinliebhaber
  • Zugang zu 295,210 Weinbewertungen und 16,091 Artikeln
  • Zugang zu The Oxford Companion to Wine und The World Atlas of Wine
  • Access askJancis, our AI wine assistant
Inner Circle
$249
/Jahr
 
Ideal für Sammler

Everything in “Member”, plus:

  • Early access to the latest wine reviews, 48 hours in advance
  • Early access to the latest articles, 48 hours in advance
Professional
$299
/Jahr
Für Weinprofis (Einzelnutzer)
  • Zugang zu 295,210 Weinbewertungen und 16,091 Artikeln
  • Zugang zu The Oxford Companion to Wine und The World Atlas of Wine
  • Access askJancis, our AI wine assistant
  • Frühzeitiger Zugang zu den neuesten Weinbewertungen und Artikeln, 48 Stunden im Voraus
  • Gewerbliche Nutzung von bis zu 25 Weinbewertungen und -punkten für Marketingzwecke
Gewerblich
$399
/Jahr
Für Unternehmen in der Weinbranche

Everything in “Professional”, plus:

  • Gewerbliche Nutzung von bis zu 250 Weinbewertungen und -punkten für Marketingzwecke
  • Access to submit wines for review
  • Offer memberships to your employees and manage them from a single place
  • API access available for an additional fee
Bezahlen Sie mit
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Abonnieren Sie unseren Newsletter

Erhalten Sie die neuesten Beiträge von Jancis und ihrem Team führender Weinexperten.

Mit dem Abonnement erklären Sie sich mit unserer Datenschutzerklärung einverstanden und stimmen zu, Updates von unserem Unternehmen zu erhalten.

More Gratis für alle

Chenin Blanxc vineyard in South Africa
Gratis für alle Jancis makes a suggestion. A version of this article is also published by the Financial Times. See also South Africa’s...
female urban hands each holding a glass of wine - Shutterstock
Gratis für alle Pauline Vicard asks, can wine still justify its cultural relevance? The answer to this question, rather than economics, may become...
Thomas Walk Vineyard in Kinsale
Gratis für alle Jancis is put in her place, by the hybrid grapes of the Emerald Isle. A shorter version of this article...
Ungrafted monastrell vines in Jumilla
Gratis für alle 4 June 2026 In advance of the 2026 Old Vine Conference on 8 June, we’re republishing this overview of our...

More from JancisRobinson.com

Jota Tanaka at Gotemba distillery
Getränke außer Wein An exploration of the transparency of Japanese whisky – and how that sensibility is influencing whiskey-making back in Scotland. Above...
Glass of rose with food
Verkostungsberichte Rosés for every occasion, from poolside pinks to robust BBQ-ready versions. We at JancisRobinson.com view the world through rose-tinted spectacles...
A bottle of Moreau Naudet Chablis
Weine der Woche A reference Chablis, albeit in a riper style, available from $39.95, £31.95 . Prompted by our recent forum discussion about...
Tertius Boshoff of Stellenrust shows off multiple Chenins in London
Verkostungsberichte The many Cape Chenins and Chenin blends shown at a big South African tasting in London in May reviewed. Tertius...
The Pacific ocean view from Flowers Vineyards
Unverblümte Meinungen Chris Howard asks, if there’s such a thing as volcanic wine, can there be oceanic wine? Above, seals on the...
Beaujolais vineyard harvest imminent
Verkostungsberichte Bien Boire (‘drinking well’) en Beaujolais is more fun than Bordeaux’s primeurs and offers plenty of excellent wines, reports Natasha...
Alessandro Campatelli of Riecine
Verkostungsberichte Pleasant surprises from a torrid year. Above, Alessandro Campatelli, director and oenologist (and now owner) at Riecine, made a 2022...
Japanese Wine by Nick Rowan - book cover
Buchrezensionen Nick Rowan’s new book is an amazingly complete guide to the wine (and cheese!) of Japan, for amateurs and professionals...
Weininspiration wöchentlich direkt in Ihr Postfach
Unser Newsletter erscheint jede Woche und ist für alle gratis
Mit Ihrem Abonnement erkennen Sie unsere Allgemeinen Geschäftsbedingungen an.