Volcanic Wine Awards | The Jancis Robinson Story | 🎁 25% off annual & gift memberships

Competition – Andrew Licudi

Wednesday 5 September 2018 • 4 min read
Image

Andrew Licudi writes, 'I am a WSET diploma graduate dividing my time between Gibraltar and Edinburgh where I am part of a long-established wine group. My professional background is engineering though, having sold my businesses, I can now concentrate on my wine addiction. I also write a monthly wine column for The Gibraltar Magazine. You kindly published my article “ A solution for Sherry?” some time ago and my entry into last year’s writing competition.' His (unedited) entry in our seminal wine competition follows.

Mr Palka our Polish neighbour and was to die in very unusual circumstances. His death turned out to be inexorably linked with my eventual and lifelong love of wine.

Edinburgh New Town has hardly changed since the seventies when we first moved into a small flat in a hilly but attractive cobbled street named after the Earl of Dundonald. Let me explain that there is nothing new about Edinburgh New Town. Chronic overcrowding and the uncontrolled, stinking effluence of the old city led to the construction of a new town over two hundred years ago. Our flat was built for the servant classes having none of the usual Georgian features of high ceilings, elaborate cornices or black marble fireplaces Above us, however, in typical New Town grandeur lived Mr Palka our Polish neighbour.

Mr Palka, in his early sixties, lived on his own. Like the shiny and self-assured black cat he kept for company, he was always immaculately turned out with a red silk handkerchief and impeccable shoes. He was polite to a fault but never stopped to chat with neighbours longer than social etiquette demanded and rarely did the subject matter get beyond the weather or some perceived fault in a communal part of the building. From the music wafting down from above and regular deliveries of wine, always in wooden cases, Mr Palka was clearly a man who enjoyed fine living. It was not uncommon to see Justerini and Brooke’s van outside our building nor the owner of the long-defunct Howgate Wines in Cumberland Street gingerly carrying a wooden case across slippery cobbles to Mr Palka’s flat.

Should you visit the New Town your attention will be drawn to the fine stone work, the astragal windows with their shimmering glass and shiny brass door handles. What you won’t see are the thousands of arched cellars beneath the wide pavements. Their wooden black doors invisible from street level, each flat allocated a cellar scrupulously recorded in property deeds. Mr Palka however appeared to own all our cellars and over the years many owners had consulted their solicitors only to be told that indeed all the cellars had been allocated to Mr Palka's flat over two hundred years before and there was nothing to be done about it. His five cellars, guarded by unusually heavy doors and double mortice locks, were rumoured to be filled with expensive French wines.

Mr Palka’s problems started on a fine Saturday morning in early summer. Answering our doorbell, I found him dishevelled but smiling. He wanted me to drive him to his doctor as his right arm had gone dead. His smile did not hide his embarrassment at his unkempt appearance and undone shoe laces.

On the way there he told me he was confident that his limp arm was a minor problem and he had no intention of cancelling a long-planned holiday with friends who had chartered a sail boat in Ecuador to visit the Galapagos Islands and would our son look after his cat? I did not answer, hoping my silence would express my thoughts without having to be over-familiar. In any case, I was confident that his doctor would dissuade him from embarking on such a foolhardy journey as his symptoms appeared more serious than Mr Palka was admitting. I was impressed none the less with his lack of self-pity and determination.

The following week after making arrangements for our 10-year-old son to look after his cat, Mr Palka departed for South America where he suffered a stroke on the high seas and died. He is buried in the British cemetery in Lima.

For a few days our dead neighbour became the central theme of conversation in our building. Had he died suddenly? How far away from land where they? Would the heat have made on board living intolerable with a dead body? Would the sharks have eaten him had they buried him at sea? Did he have any relatives? Questions which were never answered.

After our initial shock our attention turned to the cat. What were we to do with him? Mr Palka had given us a set of keys to his lavishly appointed flat for our son to carry out cat-keeping. He was to be paid on Mr Palka’s return!

A few days later Mr Palka’s solicitor, a jovial overweight man, came to the door and introducing himself, thanked us for looking after the cat and asked if we would we consider taking it in for a few days until permanent arrangements were made. He asked us to come upstairs and take whatever dishes or paraphernalia cats required which we did. As we were about to leave the lawyer called me back. “I think you will find that that Marcus is partial to fine wine!” The lawyer winked and smiled taking a heavy looking bottle of white wine from one of several cases stacked in the corridor. That weekend we drunk the wine and toasted our former neighbour.

If my Spanish grandmother’s sweet Oloroso set me off on a slow path to vinophilia when I was five, Mr Palka’s white Burgundy pushed me firmly over the edge into wine geek territory when I was past twenty. The wine was a 1966 Meursault from a producer I have long forgotten. I was amazed that a grape could sing such an intricate song of liquid gold, whose lyrics, unaided by added spirits, could easily stand shoulder to shoulder with those sherries whose words I knew so well.

The cat was collected a few days after the solicitor’s visit. We went on holiday and by the time we came back Mr Palka’s empty flat had been placed on the market. We never found out if his cellars were full of expensive French wines. If I am ever in Lima I will take flowers to Mr Palka, after all his gift is lasting me a lifetime. 

Become a member to continue reading
JancisRobinson.com 25th anniversaty logo

Celebrating 25 years of building the world’s most trusted wine community

In honour of our anniversary, enjoy 25% off all annual and gift memberships for a limited time.

Use code HOLIDAY25 to join our community of wine experts and enthusiasts. Valid through 1 January.

Member
$135
/year
Save over 15% annually
Ideal for wine enthusiasts
  • Access 286,158 wine reviews & 15,819 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
Inner Circle
$249
/year
 
Ideal for collectors
  • Access 286,158 wine reviews & 15,819 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
Professional
$299
/year
For individual wine professionals
  • Access 286,158 wine reviews & 15,819 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 25 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Business
$399
/year
For companies in the wine trade
  • Access 286,158 wine reviews & 15,819 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 250 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Pay with
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Join our newsletter

Get the latest from Jancis and her team of leading wine experts.

By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

More Free for all

My glasses of Yquem being filled at The Morris
Free for all Go on, spoil yourself! A version of this article is published by the Financial Times . Above, my glasses being...
RBJR01_Richard Brendon_Jancis Robinson Collection_glassware with cheese
Free for all What do you get the wine lover who already has everything? Membership of JancisRobinson.com of course! (And especially now, when...
Red wines at The Morris by Cat Fennell
Free for all A wide range of delicious reds for drinking and sharing over the holidays. A very much shorter version of this...
JancisRobinson.com team 15 Nov 2025 in London
Free for all Instead of my usual monthly diary, here’s a look back over the last quarter- (and half-) century. Jancis’s diary will...

More from JancisRobinson.com

Cristal 95 and 96 bottles
Tasting articles A comparative tasting of champagne from the highly acclaimed 1996 vintage and the overshadowed 1995. And a daring way to...
Sylt with beach and Strandkörbe
Nick on restaurants An annual round-up of gastronomic pleasure. Above, the German island of Sylt which provided Nick with an excess of it...
screenshot of JancisRobinson.com from 2001
Inside information The penultimate episode of a seven-part podcast series giving the definitive story of Jancis’s life and career so far. For...
Wine news in 5 logo and Bibendum wine duty graphic
Wine news in 5 Plus potential fraud in Vinho Verde, China’s recognition of Burgundy appellations, and the campaign for protected land in Australia’s Barossa...
Brokenwood Stuart Hordern and Kate Sturgess
Wines of the week A brilliantly buzzy white wine with the power to transform deliciously over many years. And prices start at just €19.90...
Fortified tasting chez JR
Tasting articles Sherry, port and Madeira in profusion. This is surely the time of year when you can allow yourself to take...
Saldanha exterior
Inside information On South Africa’s remote West Coast an unlikely fortified-wine revival is taking place. Malu Lambert reports. Saldanha’s castle is an...
Still-life photograph of bottles of wine and various herbs and spices
Inside information Part three of an eight-part series on how to pair wine with Asian flavours, adapted from Richard’s book. Click here...
Wine inspiration delivered directly to your inbox, weekly
Our weekly newsletter is free for all
By subscribing you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.