The Jancis Robinson Story | Mission Blind Tasting | Wine writing competition

Competition – Anthony Pieri

• 4 min read
Image

'Since the Table 4 Incident', Anthony Pieri writes, 'I have travelled the world working in various stages of the wine supply chain and currently live in Melbourne, Australia where I work as a Group Sommelier. I am pursuing the Master of Wine and Master Sommelier Diplomas.' He adds mysteriously, 'There is no iceberg lettuce in the house.' This is his (unedited) entry in our seminal wine competition

E.M Forster said “spoon feeding in the long run teaches us nothing but the shape of the spoon.” This baptism-by-fire, knuckle-grease rhetoric couldn’t be a more accurate distillation of my introduction to the world of wine as I stepped foot for the first time into a fine dining, European restaurant in small-town America.

The eggshell white walls were adorned with framed water colours and bathed in a soft glow of incandescent light. Soft music serenaded nothing more than napkin-folding and the scurry of mise-en-place. There were nine perfectly aligned, meticulously set tables. The butter was a perfectly piped pirouette with a single red peppercorn placed at the tip. The tablecloths were ironed. Each different type of wine had its own special glass. This speckled-face, naïve, awkward pubescent was way out of his depth.

As I tried to get a grip, my bewilderment was shattered by a man booming “good evening young sir.”

There he was, standing up to (maybe) my shoulders and 60kg soaking wet and wearing a jet-black suit, pressed white shirt and flawlessly polished shoes with his black tie folded thrice and loosely gripped in his left hand. His wrinkled, leathery scowl and thin blonde hair scrupulously combed over his balding head proved this wasn’t his first rodeo. His posture was perfect. He pivoted; looked me up and down with utter disapproval, shook my hand and introduced himself as Lawrence.

I waited tables that night after learning the menu he emailed. Table 4 ordered a bottle of Dierberg Pinot Noir and with as much counterfeit grace as I could muster, proceeded with the customary textbook drill of serving the wine, and carried on.

Five minutes later, whilst staring blankly and panicking at a homogenous monochromatic POS searching feverishly for an entrée button, Lawrence politely enquired about the wine on table 4 to which I assured him I was looking after.

He cocked his head in a split second of confusion before shooting a devilish death stare. He inhaled like a jet engine, thrusted his chest and bellowed at me in a rising crescendo to the top of his lungs “then why do our guests have empty wine glasses?! What do I look like to you, A WINE STEWARD?! GET. OUT. THERE! POUR. THE WINE! NOOOW!” of course salt and peppered with more expletives than a losing team’s locker room. The blood seemed to rush out of my face as the familiar uneasy deep-seeded feeling of doom overcame my body. No one had ever spoken to me like that before. I wobbled over to table 4 holding back tears with tingly, weak legs and hands equally as unsteady – and I poured the wine.

You see, I had no idea that after you pour the first glass, you have to continue to pour the wine again and again?! I bought ‘Lessons in Service’ and ‘The Wine Bible’ the next day, and surprisingly kept the job.

To this day, I have no idea what ever happened to that entrée.

Every night after service, the staff all sat around a table in the rathskeller with dredges of wine from the night. “I love the structure, tannins are so well integrated,” one would say, “so much finesse,” another would mumble. They all had a seemingly immense amount of respect for this grape juice. As I choked it down, I could only think to myself how on earth did the smell of a cigar-box get into the bottle, and why on earth would you want to drink it?

We also became regular patrons at the local wine bar. Adjectives were thrown around as lavishly as the tasting pours and we met with other hospitality people who were seemingly participating in this ritual of after-work banter and hedonism.

“I want a red so big I can chew it.”

“Have you heard about the vintage in California this year? It’s going to be fantastic.”

“What new Pinot’s do you have?”

“Nectarines, pears and beautiful vanilla oak, yum!”

“Dill! Smell it again, I’m getting dill!”

Lawrence would turn to me and explain in an Attenborough-esque demeanour that there was a place in France that had vineyards planted by monks in the 1300’s, and there was this widow in Champagne, and in 1855 there was a classification of wines in Bordeaux. Soil is important, Gewurztraminer smells like lychees and South Africa made wine.

Most interesting of all, a person who was a bona-fide expert in this stuff had a title! A sommelier – and all they did was talk about, sell, and drink wine all day. And there is this Court of Sommeliers, where if you study hard enough and pass the incredibly rigorous exams you can become a Master Sommelier. There was also an institute, and if you proved good enough to be invited, and pass all the exams, you could become a Master of Wine. “Nevermind,” they said, “you can’t possibly do both – it’s masochism.”

As I reeled from the post-trauma of the ‘Table 4 incident’ by which it became affectionately known, my bewilderment turned to intrigue, and I was constantly asking questions. The entire time Lawrence would sit there quietly and listen, he saw in my wide eyes that a fire had been lit.

Lawrence then started to constantly ask me questions about the world of wine. What is suissereserve? Name the first growths of Bordeaux. Name the grapes allowed in Chateauneuf-du-Pape. I would go to work early and stay late than anyone. Ten years later, I still call him to ask whether or not I should decant a Jeroboam of Dom Perignon for seamless service, or exactly how he got a broken cork out of a bottle with a piece of string and a chopstick. I still take his advice, and admire his audacity – both tableside and in life.

Turns out Mr. Forster, I know nothing about the shape of the spoon, and I have a strong-willed, patient, incredibly humbling man to thank for it.

Choose your plan
Member
$135
/year
Save over 15% annually
Ideal for wine enthusiasts
  • Access 297,330 wine reviews & 16,161 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Access askJancis, our AI wine assistant
Inner Circle
$249
/year
 
Ideal for collectors

Everything in “Member”, plus:

  • Early access to the latest wine reviews, 48 hours in advance
  • Early access to the latest articles, 48 hours in advance
Professional
$299
/year
For individual wine professionals
  • Access 297,330 wine reviews & 16,161 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Access askJancis, our AI wine assistant
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 25 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Business
$399
/year
For companies in the wine trade

Everything in “Professional”, plus:

  • Commercial use of up to 250 wine reviews & scores for marketing
  • Access to submit wines for review
  • Offer memberships to your employees and manage them from a single place
  • API access available for an additional fee
Pay with
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Join our newsletter

Get the latest from Jancis and her team of leading wine experts.

By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

More Free for all

WWC Generic image black
Free for all In this moving entry to our 2026 wine writing competition, Charlie Geoghegan writes about selecting a great pairing for the...
Alaverdi Monastery, in Akhmeta, Kakheti
Free for all The wines of Georgia continue to be surprising. A slightly shorter version of this article is published by the Financial...
Markus and Eben Sadie at Berry Bros April 2026
Free for all Leading new-wave South African wine producer is looking to the future. A version of this article is published by the...
Sam Neill
Free for all Jancis remembers the most charming wine producer she has ever met. Above, Neill in his Two Paddocks vineyard. The worlds...

More from JancisRobinson.com

The Crest Vineyard, terroir of Moutou
Wines of the week Domaine Lafage’s Moutou from the Côtes Catalanes is not only delicious but also supports environmental research in this hot, dry...
Dugladze amber Rkatsiteli, walnuts and shoti, bread cooked on the inside of an oven
Tasting articles Jancis plunges into these distinctive wines, if not the distinctive country. Above, from producer Dugladze’s website, characteristically Georgian amber Rkatsiteli...
Penfolds Magill Estate chimney and vines
Tasting articles Big reds continue to rule in Penfolds Land, but changes are on the horizon. Penfolds’ Magill Estate is pictured above...
Boscareto vineyard in the snow
Tasting articles Concluding Walter’s report on this notably accessible vintage. Today, reviews of wines from the southern and eastern villages of Castiglione...
Barale estate and vineyards
Tasting articles A final report on a tricky vintage that produced some remarkably fresh and accessible wines. Today, reviews of wines from...
Valle de Guadalupe vineyards
Inside information Mexico’s wine industry offers lessons in dealing with climate challenges, says Mexico-based journalist and sommelier Carlos Borboa. Above, vineyards in...
Richard Hemming and Hiromi Ohno outside Sushi Oono
Vinomakase Richard’s new Vinomakase column explores how the experts match wine with Japanese cuisine. For the first edition, a traditional sushi...
Hops hang from the ceiling at Dylan's at The Kings Arms in St Albans
Bite-sized A 15th-century pub with bang-up-to-date feasting in the Cathedral Quarter of St Albans. The front bar is still reassuringly pubby...
Wine inspiration delivered directly to your inbox, weekly
Our weekly newsletter is free for all
By subscribing you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.