The Jancis Robinson Story | Mission Blind Tasting | Wine writing competition

Competition – Peter McDaid

• 4 min read
Image

Peter McDaid is a London accounts manager for a UK wine importer, having worked similar positions in Barcelona and Beverly Hills. He is also the former head sommelier of Spring in London, and Firefly Bistro in Los Angeles. Here's his (unedited) entry in our seminal wine competition

‘You have to wait tables. It’s the only way’.

Lisa had had a point. If you needed quick cash in NYC, it was the only way to go. And boy, did I need cash.

I was on my second university, broke, and about to transfer to a third. Dad had royally mismanaged my financial aid package and the generous grant that had taken me from Boston to Brooklyn was about to disappear. At first I thought I could work part time – you know, double up on shifts over summer break and then wait tables weekends to fill up the coffers without terribly affecting my studies. But, of course, in a city as expensive as New York, you needed to really start racking up the tips – and therefore the hours.

So, I started at the Seaport, unwittingly working at a mob joint with plastic forks and cockroaches falling from the ceiling. Then it was a heaving, narrow Mexican cantina where Michael, the manager in false eyelashes and a floor length kimono made it clear we were only permitted to cry in the downstairs toilet.

“Not the upstairs, only the downstairs. Now, last item for briefing; I’d like to remind you we will be having nightly bag checks as too much guacamole has gone missing”.

The money was pretty solid. But once I graduated uni(haggard but fiscally sound), I decided enough was enough. Bartenders made all the money, bartenders were cool, and I was gonna be a bartender. Having zero experience was not going to get in my way.

Like any twenty-something, I puffed up my CV with creative aplomb. I’d bartended a lunch shift at the Mexican place when Donnie showed up too high on ketamine one day:

…add ‘waiter/bartender’ to this one…

I also made a few highballs during a summer job in New Hampshire:

….they’re out of business, so change waiter to ‘bartender’; no reference available…

The first few interviews didn’t go so well. I was too short, looked too young, didn’t have enough ‘attitude’. Okay, so one job, yeah, it was mine – so long as I was willing to bartend in a jock strap.

Then came Follonico.

Follonico was a top Italian restaurant just off of The Flatiron. At the time, that neighbourhood was a wasteland. But walking in, the place was just beautiful. Warm earth tones, plank hardwood, leaf-motif upholstery and dropped antique lighting. And topiaries. I didn’t even know what those were.

My heart raced a bit. This was not an ideal match, what with my steel-toed boots, black nail polish, soul patch and hoop earrings.

But I pushed through the written exam, and I did okay. I knew enough from years of taking drink orders(and taking drinks). Then there was the interview, whereupon I was asked what the hardest part of bartending was and I answered, ‘I don’t really know anything about sports’.

Which was really to cover the fact I didn’t really know anything about bartending.

But, the manager got a laugh out of it and I got my trial shift.

*

Marcy was lead for the night. She was a dour, irascible girl from Indiana. I’ve seen throw rugs with more personality, but she was swift and measured. No step was wasted and by the time Follonico really started to hum, it was clear why. I fixed my eyes on everything she did; every cocktail, spirit, mixer, glass, garnish, shake and stir. I was essentially learning how to bartend on the sly. But then came the unforeseen wrench. She was decanting a 1974 Monfortino with delicate ease, and glanced to me.

‘How’s your wine knowledge?’

My eyes widened for a moment and I was hoping Marcy hadn’t noticed. But, she had.

‘I see. Okay, look, here are the trades, behind the register. Decanter, Spectator, Enthusiast – you’ll need to get reading. Also, there’s a book called Wine for Dummies. No offense, but you’ll need that’.

‘Alright, gotcha’.

‘Cannot believe they never asked you about wine…’

There was deep disapproval from Indiana and for a moment, I thought, I can bartend in a jock, why not?

*

It was a steep learning curve, and I think it’s one you can only successfully climb when you’re twenty-three and nothing seems impossible. I put my nose into it – literally. And, it wasn’t an instant pleasure for me. Honestly, my drink of choice was a Manhattan, straight up. If I’d ever had a glass of wine before Follonico, I couldn’t remember the occasion. I was a twenty-three year old virgin.

People in London laugh when I tell them we had Etna Rosso by-the-glass – in 1998. Set you back a cool $7. Sometimes Monica di Sardegna was a special pour. Oh, how I loved that one. Yes, we had the big bangers, and the chef was wild about Amarone(I still haven’t fully warmed to those wines), but for a novice like me, it was the undervalued reds from the south of Italy that reeled me in. Aglianicos and Negroamaros that I managed to find at a Chinese grocer on Eighth Ave. I’d buy a Cannonau for $7.99, and try to make it last the week. The combination of plummy fruit, herbs and lavender, for under ten – it was an instant love affair.

A couple years later I moved to Los Angeles, became a wine director, moved to sales in Beverly Hills. And it was at that hiring exam where my Cali knowledge came up short – but my Italy scores excelled. Londoners tell me all the time how lucky I am to have begun with Italian wine; moan about how confusing it is. Yeah, I guess I really was lucky.

How ironic my New York City side hustle – the means to pay for uni – became my career. I’ve made no use of my Fine Arts Education degree. But I’ve made very good use of a very many Italian wines. And all because I was too short and wouldn’t bartend in a thong.

(still don’t know anything about sports, either)

Choose your plan
Member
$135
/year
Save over 15% annually
Ideal for wine enthusiasts
  • Access 296,238 wine reviews & 16,120 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Access askJancis, our AI wine assistant
Inner Circle
$249
/year
 
Ideal for collectors

Everything in “Member”, plus:

  • Early access to the latest wine reviews, 48 hours in advance
  • Early access to the latest articles, 48 hours in advance
Professional
$299
/year
For individual wine professionals
  • Access 296,238 wine reviews & 16,120 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Access askJancis, our AI wine assistant
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 25 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Business
$399
/year
For companies in the wine trade

Everything in “Professional”, plus:

  • Commercial use of up to 250 wine reviews & scores for marketing
  • Access to submit wines for review
  • Offer memberships to your employees and manage them from a single place
  • API access available for an additional fee
Pay with
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Join our newsletter

Get the latest from Jancis and her team of leading wine experts.

By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

More Free for all

Opus One winery
Free for all The first transatlantic joint venture Opus One involved icons of 20th century wine. A version of this article is published...
Old Vine Registry new seal 100+ years two versions
Free for all Breaking news! The Old Vine Registry is breaking records, barriers and new ground. And now, The Old Vine Registry seal...
Ronan Sayburn MS, Sarah Abbott MW and Hannah Tovey at Icons tastings 2026
Free for all Twenty-seven Chardonnay ‘icons’ from around the world served up to 18 accredited tasters. A version of this article is published...
WWC26 post-submission graphic
Free for all Great pairings – so many to choose from! A big thank you to all from Team JR. This year’s wine...

More from JancisRobinson.com

rosé picnic by Tamlyn Currin
Tasting articles 25 ways to keep refreshed despite the heat. Last week Europe experienced its worst June heatwave on record; this week...
Constantino Ramos
Wines of the week A Vinho Verde white made with the exactitude of a former chemist and the soul of a vine whisperer. From...
Opus 1979-2000 tasting 19 May 2026
Tasting articles A vertical tasting takes Jancis back to the groundbreaking beginning of this emblematic California red. Left to right in a...
Tony Bish in Tronçais forest
Don't quote me Forest terroir is as real, and as consequential, as vineyard terroir. Above, Tony Bish in the Tronçais forest in central...
Ch de Pennautier, Cabardès
Don't quote me A month that developed into one of cancellations and medications. Some older readers may remember the late Robin Kernick as...
Rudd Mt. Veeder Estate
Tasting articles Rich takes on this popular white-wine variety. Above, Rudd’s Mt Veeder Estate (© Rudd). For the last three years I...
Symington 2024 vintage ports
Tasting articles An excellent year for vintage port. No wonder every port house is releasing one or more such ports, making this...
Brit Nat tasting 2026 by Em Drake
Tasting articles Britpop move over; here comes Brít-Nat with pop-the-crown-cap controversy and edgy attitude. Henry writes On the day that the soon-to-be-legendary...
Wine inspiration delivered directly to your inbox, weekly
Our weekly newsletter is free for all
By subscribing you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.