Back to all articles
  • Jancis Robinson
Written by
  • Jancis Robinson
23 Feb 2007

Horribly early on Friday morning, sitting on the plane from Mendoza to Buenos Aires en route home and trying to file some sort of report, though it's difficult as the charming gentleman beside me is a member of one of the many originally-Italian winemaking families of Mendoza and was at our seminar yesterday so would prefer to chat. (Interesting to hear of his enthusiasm for the often derided ubiquitous Bonarda - actually the French Corbeau rather than an Italian variety.)


We eight UK judges were required, not just to lend our palates for heavy duty over three days of judging, hammering out which contentious wines deserved which sorts of medal and which gold medal winners deserved one of the nine available trophies, but to deliver our views on how the Argentine wine exporters could best improve their (currently pretty minor) position in the UK market. This seminar, another very well-run event, attracted well over 300 fee-paying participants and was apparently over-subscribed.


But the most amazing thing was that the audience was the most silent and attentive I have ever come across – this despite the fact that we were all speaking English, for which many of them needed the services of a simultaneous translator whose ingenuity must have been sorely tested at some point. Joe Fattorini's talk, which included references to Coronation Street, widgets and a particularly diverting discourse on the carbon emissions entailed in sending Mendoza's pride and joy, 800 gram bottles, around the world, must have been particularly taxing.


We all had to nominate two wines that had been successful in the UK market and these were served to everyone, and illustrated by close-ups of the packaging, while we spoke. For the record this was the running order:


Oz Clark, wine writer

Montana Sauvignon Blanc 2006 Marlborough, New Zealand

Viña Leyda, Brisas Vineyard Pinot Noir 2005, San Antonio, Chile


Henri Chapon, Hotel du Vin

Schloss Gobelsburg Gruner Veltliner Kammerner Lamm 2005, Kamptal, Austria

Casa de la Ermita Reserva 2001, Jumilla, Spain


Robert Joseph, wine writer

Stoneleigh Pinot Noir Rosé 2006, Marlborough, New Zealand

Yalumba, 'Y Series' Shiraz Viognier 2005, Barossa Valley, Australia


Adrian Atkinson, Pernod Ricard UK

Azpilicueta Reserva Rioja 2001, Rioja Alta, Spain


Peter Richards, wine writer and South American specialist

Cono Sur Pinot Noir 2005, Chile

Blason de Bourgogne, Saint-Véran 2005, Burgundy, France


Beverley Blanning MW, wine writer                                            

William Fèvre Chablis 2005, France

Novas, Organic Syrah Mourvedre 2005, Chile


Joe Fattorini, wine writer

Linda Domas, Shot Bull Rosé 2005, Fleurieu, Australia

Seigneurs d'Aiguilhe 2004 Côtes de Castillon Bordeaux, France


Jancis Robinson

d'Arenberg, The Money Spider Roussanne 2005, McLaren Vale, Australia

Jean Paul Mas, La Forge Merlot 2005, Vin de Pays d'Oc, France


None of us had conferred about our choices so it was interesting to see so many Pinots (not an Argentina speciality, though who knows what might eventually happen in the far south of the country?) and rosés – or the useful pale red style of the Linda Domas wine which Argentina could presumably do so well. We all chose our wines for different reasons. Oz to show that a big volume brand such as Montana can still communicate a sense of place; Henri to show them what sort of wines sommeliers like at the moment; Robert, for instance, to demonstrate the Syrah/Viognier combo; me to show how medium sized family companies, the sort that dominate the Argentine wine scene, can lift themselves out of the ordinary by working out what the market wants.


Our wines were in general much lighter and higher in natural acidity than the Argentine norm and all of stressed how important drinkabiity rather than sheer mass was and it all seemed to go down well.


After our presentations, which were more wide-ranging than just showing these particular wines, we were rewarded with an exceptionally fine lunch at La Bourgogne, the restaurant at Carlos Pulenta's new winery just outside town with the British ambassador and our Argentina fellow judges et al. These smart new restaurants and small hotels would not look a jot out of place in the Napa Valley - though they need a few more road signs to get the tourists there reliably.


On Monday I'll bring you the – pause for drum roll – results of our labours.