The Jancis Robinson Story | Mission Blind Tasting | Wine writing competition

Recycled recommendations

• 7 min read

Purple pager with a comment in members’ forum on the ubiquity of Casillero del Diablo reminded me that I had not published my last few months’ recommendations written for BA’s European Business Life magazine. (Those up to Nov 2006 appeared in Red, white and definitely green.) My brief was to choose one wine suitable for immediate consumption (‘for the table’) and a usually grander one ‘for the cellar’.

Some of these wines may no longer be available, for which I apologise, but I have provided links to winesearcher.com where appropriate to help you find them elsewhere. In any case I hate waste and in the spirit of recycling offer them below. March 2007 was the last edition in which these recommendations appear; I now write briefly at the beginning of most issues of BA’s international in-flight magazine High Life instead although Nick still writes at some length in Business Life, useful articles such as Eating out in Belgium that are published in nick’s food news.
 
MAR 07
 
For the table
 
Hartford Chardonnay 2004 Sonoma Coast
£13.50 Genesis Wines
 
A white wine at £13.50 a bottle may not seem like much of a bargain but I can assure you that this wine is underpriced, a relic of a most unfortunate episode which resulted in its previous UK importer (Mayfair Cellars)’s going belly up. Genesis have actually priced this wine very generously. California wines of any quality are generally horribly expensive in the UK – partly because the American market is encouraged to believe in a direct relationship between price and quality which encourages producers to price their wines particularly, erm, boldly. The Sonoma Coast encompasses some of the coolest parts of northern California and you can taste those chilly Pacific fogs in the crisp, refreshing acidity of this wine, complemented by winning coffee and toast richness of fruit. There’s no doubt that it was treated to some top quality oak, but it’s not overwhelming. In California it would not be difficult to find dozens of wines that are not as delicious as this and cost twice as much. Drink in the next year or so, with full flavoured Mediterranean-influenced dishes.
 
 
For the cellar
 
Enzo Boglietti, Fossati 2001 Barolo
£35 Majestic
 
This is expensive, but then good Barolo is always expensive. I’m recommending this for the cellar as it strikes me as a perfect example of Barolo, arguably Italy’s most famous wine, and yet it is a good five years off being ready to drink. Barolo is made in relatively small quantities from Nebbiolo grapes grown on the Langhe hills near the truffle town of Alba in Piemonte (Piedmont) in the hinterland of Turin. Nebbiolo is a very particular, fussy grape that has so far failed to thrive anywhere other than in north west Italy. It makes ageworthy wines with a particularly haunting aroma that has been described as ‘tar and roses’. Nebbiolo is not naturally especially deep coloured and the wine is not particularly full bodied compared with a typical New World Shiraz or Cabernet. Comparisons are often made with red burgundy, another perfumed but not heavy wine. This one already shows hints of autumn scents, damp mulched leaves and woodsmoke. Drink it at the end of a special meal, perhaps with nothing more distracting than slivers of fresh parmesan.
 
 
FEB 07
 
For the table
 
Domaine de la Meynard, Plan de Dieu 2005 Côtes du Rhône Villages
£5.49 M&S
 
Gather ye 2005s while ye may. This was a great, great vintage throughout France and this wine from the south-east, a new vintage of an old favourite, is no exception.
 
The warming reds of the southern Rhône Valley still seem comforting at this time of year and Marks & Spencer have this particularly succulent little number carrying the name of one of four new areas or villages that have recently been promoted in status there. Plan de Dieu joins names such as Valrééas, Visan, Sablet and Chusclan that can be cited on the labels of Côtes du Rhône Villages wines, those from villages recognised as producing superior wine.
 
As is usual for the wines of the southern Rhône such as Châteauneuf-du-Pape and all its satellite appellations, this full-bodied, rich, super-powerful wine is made from a cocktail of different grape varieties: 67 per cent Grenache, 22 per cent Syrah and 11 per cent Carignan in this case. I would serve this wine any time over the next 12 months with a dish with a rich mix of flavours too – casseroles, daubes and stews.
 
 
For the cellar
 
Domaine Lignier-Michelot burgundies
From £26.20 a bottle or £185 a dozen in bond, Haynes Hanson & Clark
 
Burgundy is a bit of a minefield. There are hundreds of individual vineyards shared, sometimes row by row, between hundreds of growers, an increasing proportion of whom make wine themselves rather than sell to the big merchant bottlers.
 
Famous domaines, as burgundy wine holdings are called, tend to have relativelyi high prices to reflect that fame so I am always on the look out for less well known producers who turn up on my radar and seem to be offering reliably superior quality.
 
At a recent tasting of 2004 burgundies imported into the UK by Burgundy specialists Haynes Hanson & Clark, I was struck by the unusual consistency of red burgundies from Domaine Lignier-Michelot. This well-connected young producer Virgile Lignier, is based in the village of Chambolle-Musigny and can offer 2004s such as a sumptuous Chambolle from especially old vines and two even more complex, and slower-maturing, wines from Morey. Definitely a name to watch, and these 2004s are designed to be drunk over the next five to 10 years.
 
 
JAN 07
 
For the table
 
Classic Côtes du Rhône 2005
£3.49 Waitrose
 
This is a cracking price for belt-tightening January. Along with Bordeaux Rouge and Beaujolais, Côtes du Rhône is one of France’s standard reds, produced in almost unbelievable quantity. In general it’s a better bet than either Bordeaux or Beaujolais because it is made from hearty grapes grown further south, so benefiting from extra ripeness and flavour. Nevertheless the quality of Côtes du Rhône varies enormously but this is an extremely good one for the price. Waitrose have put together their own blend of 90 per cent Grenache and 10 per cent Syrah grown around Tulette in the southern Rhône where the most famous wine is the cockle-warming Châteauneuf-du-Pape. This rich, warming red has no rough edges and is as comforting as your favourite pillow.
 
As practically everywhere else in France, and in much of Europe, 2005 was a superlative vintage. Drink this unoaked wine – full of relatively simple fruit – straightaway, and certainly by next Christmas.
 
For the cellar
 
Ch La Croix des Moines 2001 Lalande de Pomerol
£12.99 Adnams of Southwold
 
 
The 2001 vintage is one of those that has been overlooked and underpriced in Bordeaux. It followed the 2000 which was not only numerically memorable but climatologically too so that the wines were plump, ripe and concentrated and are extremely robustly priced. The 2001s are less bumptious and alcoholic but many of them are very fine with great structure. It was particularly successful in St Emilion and Pomerol, the so-called ‘left bank’ of Bordeaux (as opposed to Médoc and Graves on the ‘right bank’ of the Gironde estuary). Here we have delicious proof in the form of a blend made by energetic Bordeaux vigneron Jean-Louis Trocard from 80 per cent juicy Merlot grapes and 10 per cent each of Cabernet Sauvignon and 10 per cent Cabenet Franc – a typical right bank blend. It’s already full, round and flattering to taste in the plummy, velvety way of Pomerol. (Lalande de Pomerol is a less expensive but increasingly fashionable appellation to the immediate north of the château-dotted plateau of Pomerol.) There’s even a hint of game in the bouquet which should continue to give pleasure for the next four years or so. Drink it with substantial main courses.
 
 
DEC 06
 
For the table
 
Clos d’Yvigne, Le Petit Prince 2003 Côtes de Bergerac
£7.99 Majestic
 
You may have read about Patricia Atkinson, the plucky Englishwoman who took over an ailing vineyard in south west France and personally transformed it into a going concern making stunning sweet wine, Clos d’Yvigne Saussignac which posh wine merchant Justerini & Brooks sells for £20 a half-litre. She has written two books, The Ripening Sun and La Belle Saison, about her adventures.
 
This is the first of her dry wines I tasted and it hit me between the eyes with its wonderfully vibrant, deep-flavoured fruit positively vibrating with life and health. It doesn’t suffer from the common fault of so many European wines made in the heatwave vintage of 2003, heat on the finish, hollowness in the middle and raisined, dead fruit flavours. It’s made of the two less famous Bordeaux grape varieties, Merlot with Cabernet Franc rather than Cabernet Sauvignon, and actually tastes almost more like a super-ripe Loire red made from Cabernet Franc than like a wine from the neighbouring Bordeaux region.
 
Delicious now, it should drink well over the next two or three years. Ridiculously underpriced.
 
For the cellar
 
Graham’s Malvedos 1996 port
£22.50 Tanners of Shrewsbury, also at Fareham Wine Cellar, The Vintage House and Four Walls Wine Company
 
Stunning value, this single quinta wine from Quinta dos Malvedos, the isolated estate in the Douro Valley in northern Portugal that provides most of the best grapes for Graham’s vintage port, is well up to the standard of most vintage port. It is widely acknowledged that 1996 would have been ‘declared’ a year in which full-blown vintage port was made if it hadn’t been for the fact that 1994 had been declared and it was felt the market couldn’t bear another vintage so soon.
 
This wine is looking gorgeous now – just right for winter sipping. Wonderfully mellow yet refreshing super-ripe fruit too. Stand the bottle upright for a quarter of an hour and then, ideally, pour the wine off the thick sediment into a jug or decanter before serving. This and some good farmhouse cheddar would make a great end to any December dinner, or Christmas lunch. This port should also continue to develop in bottle for another 10 years at least.
 
Choose your plan
Member
$135
/year
Save over 15% annually
Ideal for wine enthusiasts
  • Access 296,861 wine reviews & 16,129 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Access askJancis, our AI wine assistant
Inner Circle
$249
/year
 
Ideal for collectors

Everything in “Member”, plus:

  • Early access to the latest wine reviews, 48 hours in advance
  • Early access to the latest articles, 48 hours in advance
Professional
$299
/year
For individual wine professionals
  • Access 296,861 wine reviews & 16,129 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Access askJancis, our AI wine assistant
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 25 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Business
$399
/year
For companies in the wine trade

Everything in “Professional”, plus:

  • Commercial use of up to 250 wine reviews & scores for marketing
  • Access to submit wines for review
  • Offer memberships to your employees and manage them from a single place
  • API access available for an additional fee
Pay with
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Join our newsletter

Get the latest from Jancis and her team of leading wine experts.

By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

More Free for all

Emptied plates and glasses after a meal by Jason Lowe
Free for all The joy of a roadside diner, by Charlie Geoghegan. Photo by Jason Lowe. There’s this old building by the side...
Opus One winery
Free for all The first transatlantic joint venture Opus One involved icons of 20th century wine. A version of this article is published...
Old Vine Registry new seal 100+ years two versions
Free for all Breaking news! The Old Vine Registry is breaking records, barriers and new ground. And now, The Old Vine Registry seal...
Ronan Sayburn MS, Sarah Abbott MW and Hannah Tovey at Icons tastings 2026
Free for all Twenty-seven Chardonnay ‘icons’ from around the world served up to 18 accredited tasters. A version of this article is published...

More from JancisRobinson.com

Harvest at Robert Weil by Peter Quirin.jpg
Tasting articles A year of extraordinary balance, bright acidity and some of the best Gutsweine in recent memory. Plus a whole lot...
chickens in the HJW vineyard at Hermann J Wiemer, Seneca Lake
Wines of the week The dry white wine that established New York’s Finger Lakes as the Riesling mecca of the US. And it’s only...
cheddars, apples and fruity red wine
Inside information Real cheddar for real wine. By some small miracle I manage to locate the one with four functioning wheels. My...
Monty on the beach at Betty’s Bay, near Hemel-en Aarde
Tasting articles Coolness and light in bottles from some of South Africa’s best producers. Above, Monty enjoys the cool surf in Betty’s...
Chris Keets (left) and Banele Vanele (right)
Tasting articles Proof that South Africa remains one of the most rewarding countries for wine. Above, Chris Keets (left) of Weather Report...
Lasseter Trinity Ridge Vineyard - Michael Housewright photography
Tasting articles The combination of historic vineyards, high elevation, volcanic soils and organic viticulture make this little-known AVA stand out. Above, Lasseter...
Cotta vineyard
Tasting articles Temptingly fresh and approachable wines from a heatwave year. Sottimano produced one of the most ageworthy wines of the vintage...
view towards Barbaresco
Tasting articles Wines from vintage 2022 and earlier that prove Barbaresco’s ageability. The late releases of Barbaresco 2022 put to bed two...
Wine inspiration delivered directly to your inbox, weekly
Our weekly newsletter is free for all
By subscribing you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.