Volcanic Wine Awards | 25th anniversary events | The Jancis Robinson Story

Are NZ wines good value?

Sunday 18 November 2001 • 4 min read

Cloudy Bay, New Zealand's most famous Sauvignon Blanc, is the most extraordinary wine. Not so much for how it tastes – nowadays it has many a challenger in its trailblazing pungent, piercing, defiantly New World style – but for how much it is loved.

I find it difficult to think of any other single wine with quite so many fans among the great mass of casual wine drinkers. Once these people get a sniff of the razor-sharp acidity that characterises New Zealand wines plus Sauvignon's greengage razzle on the palate, they just will not let it go. They plead to be able to buy it by the case and every autumn pick wine lists bare of it as soon as the year's allocation arrives in the northern hemisphere.

Nowadays Cloudy Bay Sauvignon is made in serious quantities – quite enough for Britain's biggest supermarket chain Tesco to have been able to offer it by the dozen, for example, as a come-on for its new online Wine Warehouse (£136.68 at www.tesco.com), for example (NB stocks have currently been exhausted but they will be repeating the offer in the next few weeks). It has also become a sufficiently tall poppy for many a wine professional to have taken a sideswipe at it over the past few years.

It is this sweetish, hit-on-the-head style that has led New Zealand wine's march into Britain, by far its most important importer, accounting for about half of all wine exported from this relatively small country. (The Darling co-op in South Africa, for example, produces more wine than the whole of New Zealand.) Prices of New Zealand wine have remained pretty steep, partly because of the Cloudy Bay syndrome and partly because quantities produced are relatively small.

After years of consistent growth however, Britain's imports of NZ wine fell back in the 12 months to June 2001. Admittedly, this was compensated for by recent increases in American imports of wine from New Zealand as the dominant company Montana (recently ceded to Allied Domecq) launched its Brancott brand in the US, but I suspect New Zealand wine producers will have to work hard increasingly hard to argue that their wines represent good value in an international context.

This is certainly true for Pinot Noir, the red burgundy grape variety New Zealanders are working hard to make their own, in the business today. And so few of them have much capacity for ageing.

But at least New Zealand's producers of Pinot Noir can be comforted by the fact that there is a global shortage of half-decent examples of this finicky grape, which demands a relatively cool climate to ripen in a sufficiently interesting way. The competition is much tougher for most of New Zealand's other reds, which can be delicious – but if they are, they are often lauded to the skies back home and cost the earth. However well-made NZ's best Bordeaux blends such as Esk Valley's The Terraces, Stonyridge Larose and Te Mata are, they are so revered back home that they can look just too expensive on export markets, particularly those awash with claret from elsewhere.

 

Perhaps even more exciting is that New Zealand is now producing some promising other white varietals, particularly Pinot Gris and Riesling (the latter both sweet and dry) – even if development has been slightly hampered by the fact that the late Professor Helmut Becker, the wine industry's guru in the 1970s and 1980s, encouraged it to import high-yielding clones from Geisenheim in Germany.

The key to finding value in New Zealand wine is either to catch a shipment from a producer who is just starting to export and is not yet too greedy (Alan McCorkindale's new Spy Valley Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc and Pinot Noir from Bibendum Wines of London NW1 and Broadbent Wine Selections of San Francisco springs to mind), or to get your hands on some of the following:

  • Kim Crawford Dry Riesling 2001 Marlborough
    £8.99 Butlers Wine Cellar of Brighton, Luvian's Bottle Shop of Cupar in Fife, Norman Gardner Wines of London SW16, Oasis Wines of Southend, Selfridges of London W1 and Wadebridge Wines of Cornwall.

     

  • Dry River, Martinborough
    Farr Vintners of London SW1, Justerini & Brooks of London SW1 and Raeburn Fine Wines of Edinburgh.
    Undoubtedly the most cerebral wine producer in NZ, who sends tiny quantities to Britain each year, largely for sentimental rasons (he is an Oxford alumnus). The Pinot Noir is most famous but Syrah, Riesling and Pinot Gris can be exceptional too.
     
  • Gibbston Valley Riesling 2000/2001 Central Otago
    £11.99 New World Wines of London SW11.
    Both these vintages are very fine, eerily pure and off-dry. Great aperitifs.
     
  • Hatton Estate Hawkes Bay
    About £18. 

    I have tasted only one wine from this new producer, a 1998 Cabernet/Merlot, but it struck me as one of the liveliest blends from the heavily-touted Gimblett Gravels subregion whose wines can sometimes be too much of a good thing.

  • Isabel Estate Sauvignon Blanc 2001 Marlborough
    £9.90 Morris & Verdin of London SE1, Adventures in Wine of Daly City, CA 94014 (AIW@ix.netcom.com).
    Very distinctive, Sancerre-like style – much drier than most. More expensive than many fine Sancerre 2000s though.
     
  • Kingsley Estate Hawkes Bay
    About £20. (www.kingsley.co.nz)
     
  • Matakana Estate Pinot Gris 2000 Warkworth
    Berkmann Wine Cellars, London N7 (tel 0207 609 4711) or email (cellar@matakana-estate.co.nz).
    Not the best, but one of the best value.
     
  • C J Pask Hawkes Bay
    £9-20 Lay & Wheeler of Colchester.
    One of the most impressive producers of Bordeaux reds with a long track record. Recently blotted its copybook by misleading labelling of Sauvignon Blanc imported from Chile to compensate for Hawkes Bay's tiny 2001 crop. It also once had to take the incendiary word 'powerful' off a label bound for the US.
     
  • Stonecroft Syrah 1998 Hawkes Bay
    £13.95 Lea & Sandeman of London SW10, W8, SW13 and NW3.
    Quite the most successful Syrah in New Zealand. Round and flavoursome without being overripe.
     
  • Unison Selection 1998/99
    £15.95 Waitrose's top stores.
    Both vintages are an impressively-knit blend of Bordeaux varieties with Syrah. Serious stuff.
     
  • Villa Maria Reserve Clifford Bay Sauvignon Blanc 2001 Marlborough
    £10.99 Oddbins and Michael Skurnik Wines of Syosset, NY 11791.
    Smoky with real lift and excitement.

For other stockists see WineSearcher.
For more information on New Zealand wines try www.nzwine.com or Wine and Food Associates in New York (tel +1 212 505 1616, fax +1 212 505 1723, email rcallahan@earthlink.net) or David Strada in San Francisco (tel +1 415 567 5511, fax +1 415 567 9011, email dstrada@rocketmail.com).

Choose your plan
Member
$135
/year
Save over 15% annually
Ideal for wine enthusiasts
  • Access 289,327 wine reviews & 15,901 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
Inner Circle
$249
/year
 
Ideal for collectors
  • Access 289,327 wine reviews & 15,901 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
Professional
$299
/year
For individual wine professionals
  • Access 289,327 wine reviews & 15,901 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 25 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Business
$399
/year
For companies in the wine trade
  • Access 289,327 wine reviews & 15,901 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 250 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Pay with
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Join our newsletter

Get the latest from Jancis and her team of leading wine experts.

By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

More Free for all

A bunch of green Kolorko grapes on the vine in Türkiye
Free for all This morning at Wine Paris, Dr José Vouillamoz and Seyit Karagözoğlu of Paşaeli Winery made the surprising announcement that Kolorko...
Clisson, copyright Emeline Boileau
Free for all Jancis revels in the glorious 2025 Loire vintage, and her tasting of dry whites identifies some excellent 2024s, too. A...
White wine grapes from Shutterstock
Free for all Favourites among the quirkier vine varieties. A shorter version of this article, with fewer recommendations, is published by the Financial...
Kim Chalmers
Free for all Kim Chalmers of Chalmers Wine and Chalmers Nursery in Victoria is no stranger to JancisRobinson.com. She was an important influence...

More from JancisRobinson.com

Farr Southwold lunch
Tasting articles See this guide to our coverage of 2022 bordeaux, and our report on the 2022 bordeaux whites tasted during this...
Tom Parker, Jean-Marie Guffens and Stephen Browett (L to R) taken in Guffens’ base in France's Mâconnais
Tasting articles The first of three reports on this year’s blind tasting of significant four-year-old bordeaux. See Bordeaux 2022 – a guide...
Diners in Hawksmoor restaurant, London, in the daytime
Nick on restaurants Nick reports on a global dining trend. Above, diners at Hawksmoor in London. My frequent conversations with our restaurateur son...
Maison Mirabeau and Wine News in 5 logo
Wine news in 5 Also, Concha y Toro set to purchase Provence estate Mirabeau (shown above); an update on Facebook’s recent recommendation bans and...
Greywacke's Clouston Vineyard, in Wairau Valley, New Zealand
Wines of the week Exemplary New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc from the Wairau Valley, pictured above. From $17.99, £23.94. It was not my intent to...
Famille Lieubeau Muscadet vineyards in winter
Tasting articles From crisp, mineral Muscadet to racy Chardonnay, Chenin and Sauvignon Blanc, plus some Grolleau Gris and reds from Gamay and...
Sam Cole-Johnson blind tasting at her table
Mission Blind Tasting Learn to taste – and think – like a wine pro. Whether you’re studying for a wine exam or just...
Vignoble Roc’h-Mer aerial view
Inside information A continuation of Chris Howard’s two-part exploration of the newly revived wine regions of north-west France. Above, an aerial view...
Wine inspiration delivered directly to your inbox, weekly
Our weekly newsletter is free for all
By subscribing you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.