Volcanic Wine Awards | The Jancis Robinson Story | 🎁 25% off annual & gift memberships

Spanish relic stars at lunch and dinner

Thursday 22 February 2018 • 5 min read
Image

22 February We are republishing this free in our Throwback Thursday series. 

5 February This is the first of five articles we plan to publish in a special week devoted to Spain. 

I’d like to have gone to this year’s Australia Day Tasting on 23 January but I had a long-standing commitment to a long-sitting lunch with nine fellow pensioners. (I’m sure Richard did a great job of covering the ADT instead.) 

Some may remember my account of the last get-together of the 1950 Babes in 2015, a group of us in and around the UK wine trade born in 1950. We used to meet only every 10 years but realised that, ahem, it might be wiser to meet more often than that, so we agreed to subject ourselves to another bibulous gathering before our planned 2020 celebration of reaching our eighth decade.

Berry Bros & Rudd very kindly agreed to provide the setting again, an upper dining room at 3 St James’s Street; the host, recently retired Simon Berry; and some extremely superior food. We paid for the food and brought our own wine. In quantity.

Because we used to be more numerous, and there were some fairly late falls by the wayside, we had been asked to provide a magnum each, which of course turned out to be far too much for a table of nine. Where participants had provided two bottles instead of a magnum, we opened just one bottle (two in the case of a premoxed white burgundy). As for the magnums, I hope that the delightful serving staff were able to enjoy the leftovers.

Those who made it this time around, apart from the hardy female 1950-vintage Masters of Wine (me and fellow wine writer Rosemary George), were Tony Stebbings of Smooth Red, who undertook all the organisation, Allan Cheesman, who ran Sainsbury’s wine department in the glory days, Tim How, who was boss of Majestic wine warehouses ditto, Gerald Duff of Unwins wine stores ditto, Bill Rolfe, who dreamt up Pink Elephant rosé, David Hunter ex Sichel and WSET, and Tim Littler, who has jumped from Whitham fine-wine traders to travel via Golden Eagle Luxury Trains. He was just off to Ecuador.

But before then there were 12 wines and four courses demanding our attention. We gathered with a couple of bottles of champagne in one of the cosy drawing rooms that Berrys now field. Three classic whites at three very different stages of maturity accompanied our seriously refined wild mushroom tart with quail’s eggs, salsify and hollandaise.

Then we picked at four red bordeaux with the roast and confit duck with its delicious little patty, followed by British cheeses stilton, Baron Bigod and Coolea, but most were agreed that the red wine star of the show was an extraordinary wild card I brought along from Spain (see below).

The Sauternes and the port (the only representative of our birth year) were just the job for the delicate riff on rhubarb cheesecake.

My tasting notes are below, but what did we talk about? Absent friends, wine-trade gossip ancient and modern, the parlous state of wine retailing in the UK and, I’m sure, much, much more.

Inter alia I told the story of the extraordinary red magnum I had supplied which was entirely due to the kindness and perspicacity of our Spanish specialist Ferran Centelles, always the source of great ideas. The Cariñena co-op (professionally known and approved by several of my colleagues round the table) celebrated its half-century last year by releasing a few extraordinarily packaged magnums of a stunning Garnacha that had been donated to the enterprise on its founding by one of its members. Its precise origins are unknown but the wine is thought to have been already 10 to 15 years old when the co-op was founded.

Ferran had kindly sent magnums to our JancisRobinson.com Christmas dinner on 15 December so that we could enjoy one together that night and then everyone could take one home. As you can see from the picture above of the empties on the morning of 16 December, this excitingly vibrant rich wine was packaged in most unusual magnum bottle shape (second magnum from the right) and labelled with simply typed labels tied on with string. No design agency could have bettered this look. See immediately below for close-up of the suitably wine-spattered label leftover from our 1950s lunch and a bit further below for my tasting note on this wine, and on the other 11 wines we enjoyed at the recent Vintage 1950 lunch.

I'm afraid the prevailing spirit of our JancisRobinson.com Christmas dinner was fun rather than work so I did not take tasting notes on what was served but there was a strong Spanish element because Ferran had taken the trouble to fly over from Barcelona for the night, and a fine Italian magnum to acknowledge Walter's presence.

The wines for the 14 of us (alas, Alder, Elaine, Max and even Michael were too far-flung to join us) were a magnum of Pol Roger 2002 Champagne, two bottles of Keller, Kirchspiel Riesling GG 2009 Rheinhessen, a magnum of Il Palazzone Riserva 2004 Brunello di Montalcino, a magnum of Ridge Monte Bello 1991 Santa Cruz Mountains, the magnum of Cariñena from the 1950s described above and below and a magnum of Chivite, Colección 125 Vendimia Tardia 2001 Navarra. All were in great shape, even the super-sweet Spaniard at the end.

But again, it was the extraordinary Cariñena that elicited most comment and wonder. Is not wine a wonderful thing?

White

This was a slightly disappointing, inexpressive bottle without the usual drama of Dom P. Not much intensity, though it was still quite tight. Perhaps, because the 2008 is so unready, it was released a little too soon to plug a sales gap? (JR)

Drink: 2019 – 2024
White

Rich, dark and intensely mushroomy. This style of champagne is one you love or loathe – it is so defiantly mature. Some of our 1950s group found it too much. I agree it is too much to sip as an aperitif but I think it could inspired some wonderful food matches: chicken with morels and a creamy sauce perhaps? Certainly not a thirst-quencher... (JR)

Drink: 1995 – 2020
White

Magnum. This lovely wine was a gift from Jean-Christophe Mau to our 1950s Babes lunch.
Pale, very slightly oaky still on the nose. Lots of fun with a certain slightly oily sweetness but kept fresh by its blackcurrant-leaf aroma and correct acidity. Far from thin but very promising for the future. If I saw this on a wine list I would probably grab it with both hands. It looks to be well distributed in the US where it retails from about $30 a bottle. (JR)

Drink: 2017 – 2024
White

Chablis-expert Rosemary George MW very kindly supplied two bottles of this wine.
Alas they were both unpleasantly oxidised. For a few minutes the second one offered freshness as well as richness but then followed the first down the plughole. What a shame. A pox on premox... (JR)

Drink: 2008 – 2017
White

Magnum generously donated by Tim Littler who has long championed the wines of Louis Latour and claims you have to wait many a long year for them to prove their worth – even this one from the notorious heatwave year.
This deep gold, almost viscus wine was very rich indeed – teetering on the edge of heaviness – but with great vibrancy and huge appeal. Perhaps not the most complex but miles better than many a Corton-Charlemagne. (JR)

Drink: 2010 – 2022
Red

Another magnum donated by Jean-Christophe Mau, and another extremely user-friendly bordeaux.
Very deep crimson, modern but not excessive style. This would be a great wine to use to introduce neophytes to bordeaux with. Suave, fresh with masses of maturing fruit and the tannins present but not dominant. No great complexity yet but very well made. (JR)

Drink: 2019 – 2032
Red

I fear this may always be a little skinny and austere. It has not mellowed substantially over time and is still a little too tough and tart for its fruit weight. It won't fall off a cliff but I'm not sure it's worth waiting too long for. (JR)

Drink: 2014 – 2023
Red

Magnum. Delightfully rich and a great undertow. Slightly dry finish but excellent depth of fruit on the palate. This, from what was rarely a charming vintage, has lasted admirably. (JR)

Drink: 2010 – 2022
Red

Magnum. This is what claret is all about. Utterly correct, bone dry, straight-backed, not opulently fleshy nor fruity (cf Ch Brown 2010) but fresh and racy. Super-appetising. A health drink? Certainly not for sipping without food but this went admirably with the duck provided for us 1950s babes. (JR)

Drink: 2000 – 2030
Red

Magnum – and what a magnum! Sniffed out and provided by Ferran Centelles. An extraordinary rich, mature, lively wine that is believed to be the produce of one of the founding members of the Cariñena co-op. They brought the wines they had made in the previous 10 to 15 years to donate to the co-op and store there. This one was stored in concrete apparently (if I have translated the label correctly) until being put into distinctive magnums to celebrate the co-op's half-century in 2017.
This bright ruby wine was broad, biscuity and spicy with a touch of gaminess. Muscular, well structured and sweet, it proves just how good Garnacha can be. It reminded me on the nose of a particularly complex tea. Glorious. (JR)

Alcohol: 13.5%
Drink: 1987 – 2030
White

Dark tawny. Rich but also managed to be extremely fresh and lively. Great stuff! It looked much older than it tasted. (JR)

Drink: 1995 – 2030
Red

This bottle had come from Ireland where it may well have been bottled but it was in great shape.
Pale tawny colour but still sweet and complex with a certain graininess. Very encouraging to see that a wine as old as the company round the table was still so vigorous – even if supposedly from a 'light' vintage. Huh. (JR)

Drink: 1975 – 2030
Become a member to continue reading

Celebrating 25 years of building the world’s most trusted wine community

In honour of our anniversary, enjoy 25% off all annual and gift memberships for a limited time.

Use code HOLIDAY25 to join our community of wine experts and enthusiasts. Valid through 1 January.

Member
$135
/year
Save over 15% annually
Ideal for wine enthusiasts
  • Access 285,307 wine reviews & 15,800 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
Inner Circle
$249
/year
 
Ideal for collectors
  • Access 285,307 wine reviews & 15,800 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
Professional
$299
/year
For individual wine professionals
  • Access 285,307 wine reviews & 15,800 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 25 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Business
$399
/year
For companies in the wine trade
  • Access 285,307 wine reviews & 15,800 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 250 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Pay with
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Join our newsletter

Get the latest from Jancis and her team of leading wine experts.

By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

More Free for all

JancisRobinson.com team 15 Nov 2025 in London
Free for all Instead of my usual monthly diary, here’s a look back over the last quarter- (and half-) century. Jancis’s diary will...
Skye Gyngell
Free for all Nick pays tribute to two notable forces in British food, curtailed far too early. Skye Gyngell is pictured above. To...
Kistler Chardonnay being poured at The Morris
Free for all Recommendations of very varied wines for very varied budgets, from £11.50 to £60 a bottle. A much shorter version of...
Cornas view © Bernard Favre
Free for all A guide to all our coverage of vintage 2024 in the Rhône Valley. Master of Wine and Rhône expert Alistair...

More from JancisRobinson.com

Karl and Alex Fritsch in winery; photo by Julius_Hirtzberger.jpg
Wines of the week A rare Austrian variety revived and worthy of a place at the table. From €13.15, £20.10, $24.19. It was pouring...
Windfall vineyard Oregon
Tasting articles The fine sparkling-wine producers of Oregon are getting organised. Above, Lytle-Barnett’s Windfall vineyard in the Eola-Amity Hills, Oregon (credit: Lester...
Mercouri peacock
Tasting articles More than 120 Greek wines tasted in the Peloponnese and in London. This peacock in the grounds of Mercouri estate...
Wine Snobbery book cover
Book reviews A scathing take on the wine industry that reminds us to keep asking questions – about wine, and about everything...
bidding during the 2025 Hospices de Beaune wine auction
Inside information A look back – and forward – at the world’s oldest wine charity auction, from a former bidder. On Sunday...
hen among ripe grapes in the Helichrysum vineyard
Tasting articles The wines Brunello producers are most proud of from the 2021 vintage, assessed. See also Walter’s overview of the vintage...
Haliotide - foggy landscape
Tasting articles Wines for the festive season, pulled from our last month of tastings. Above, fog over the California vineyards of Haliotide...
Leonardo Berti of Poggio di Sotto
Tasting articles Following Walter’s overview of the vintage last Friday, here’s the first instalment of his wine reviews. Above, Leonardo Berti, winemaker...
Wine inspiration delivered directly to your inbox, weekly
Our weekly newsletter is free for all
By subscribing you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.