25th anniversary events | The Jancis Robinson Story | 🎁 25% off gift memberships

Dom de l’Ecu, Granite 2005 Muscadet de Sèvre-et-Maine

Friday 5 September 2008 • 3 min read
Image

Find this wine

I found this wine via an extremely circuitous route. Hugh Johnson asked me en passant whether I had tasted a range of French wines specially selected, but not made, by Anne-Claude Leflaive of Domaine Leflaive in Puligny-Montrachet. This piqued my curiosity and I tracked them down to their UK importer Armit who, most unfortunately for the average wine drinker, sell only by the case (six bottles in this instance). Although in this case, my wine of the week is such good value, and should drink well for several years, that perhaps six bottles is a sensible minimum rather than too many.  

These Leflaive selections are wines made by Anne-Claude’s fellow organic or biodynamic winemaker friends (amis vignerons) with special front labels featuring a picture of her and back labels giving a quite admirable amount of detail, including how long to keep the wine, what to eat with it, the background of the wine and winemaker and, all important in this case, the terroir. I know that many back labels claim to give this sort of information but too often it reads as though it were generated by a computer, or very junior member of staff. In this case, the advice seems entirely credible.

The range comprises 22 wines in all apparently, and at Domaine  Leflaive they have moved on to the 2006 vintage, but Armit have imported only three, all from the great 2005 vintage. Needless to say, having passed through an extra pair of hands, the wines are not cheap. In the UK six bottles of the two whites cost £62 and the red is £92. In fact the red was my least favourite. Les Amis Vignerons d’Anne-Claude Leflaive, Pinot Noir 2005 Monthelie is a wine from Eric de Suremain billed as Bourgogne Côte de Beaune. I found it very correct but a bit too lean and sinewy. Maybe a nice wine to drink fairly cool with some cold beef and salad but no more.

Les Amis Vignerons d’Anne-Claude Leflaive, Chardonnay sur Argile 2005 Vin de Pays de Saône et Loire seems much more successful, as perhaps one might expect from a woman who makes some of the world’s most famous white burgundies. This Brionnais wine comes from that bit of south west of Burgundy that is bisected by the upper river Loire. Made from young Chardonnay vines grown on clay soil, it is admirably characterful. I found a heady scent of hazelnuts with real life on the palate with more than a hint of something mineral. This polished wine is just 12.5% alcohol. It’s quite crunchy, like a crisp apple, and very confident. I gave it 16.5 points.

But, most unusually, I gave the third wine, a Muscadet from Guy Bossard (pictured above) of the biodynamic Domaine de l’Ecu, 18 points. It is a quite stunning wine which can also be found under Bossard’s own Domaine de l’Ecu label. Les Amis Vignerons d’Anne-Claude Leflaive, Melon sur Granite 2005 Muscadet de Sèvre et Maine is one of the most remarkable white wines I have come across this year. Like the Chardonnay, it brims with life and confidence, a quality which may sound whimsical in a wine but I really do think some wines have it and most don’t. This Muscadet is not especially full bodied – just 12% alcohol – but it has massive extract and character. Lime zest is one strong flavour but overall the wine is more mineral than fruity – presumably from the granite on which these Melon de Bougrogne grapes were grown – yet deliciously succulent. I found it an eye opener for its density, character and depth of flavour. I believe it is likely to drink well for at least another two years and possibly three, which is quite a feat for a Muscadet.

Apparently these Anne-Claude Leflaive selections have now been sold into Japan, Holland, Switzerland and Brazil, and winesearcher.com lists several retailers in the US and one each in Canada and Singapore under the Domaine de l’Ecu label. Guy Bossard himself has none left, and bitterly regrets the fact. In the UK, both Artisan Wines and Genesis Wines currenty stock his various geologically labelled 2006s.

 

选择方案
JancisRobinson.com 25th anniversaty logo

This February, share what you love.

February is the month of love and wine. From Valentine’s Day (14th) to Global Drink Wine Day (21st), it’s the perfect time to gift wine knowledge to the people who matter most.

Gift an annual membership and save 25%. Offer ends 21 February.

会员
$135
/year
每年节省超过15%
适合葡萄酒爱好者
  • 存取 289,648 条葡萄酒点评 & 15,919 篇文章
  • 存取《牛津葡萄酒指南》《世界葡萄酒地图集》
核心会员
$249
/year
 
适合收藏家
  • 存取 289,648 条葡萄酒点评 & 15,919 篇文章
  • 存取《牛津葡萄酒指南》《世界葡萄酒地图集》
  • 提前 48 小时获取最新葡萄酒点评与文章
专业版
$299
/year
供个人葡萄酒专业人士使用
  • 存取 289,648 条葡萄酒点评 & 15,919 篇文章
  • 存取《牛津葡萄酒指南》《世界葡萄酒地图集》
  • 提前 48 小时获取最新葡萄酒点评与文章
  • 可将最多 25 条葡萄酒点评与评分 用于市场宣传(商业用途)
商务版
$399
/year
供葡萄酒行业企业使用
  • 存取 289,648 条葡萄酒点评 & 15,919 篇文章
  • 存取《牛津葡萄酒指南》《世界葡萄酒地图集》
  • 提前 48 小时获取最新葡萄酒点评与文章
  • 可将最多 250 条葡萄酒点评与评分 用于市场宣传(商业用途)
Pay with
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Join our newsletter

Get the latest from Jancis and her team of leading wine experts.

By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

More Wines of the week

Two bottles of Pikes Riesling on a table with two partly filled wine glasses beside each bottle
Wines of the week 专业人士推荐的性价比优秀的可靠雷司令 (Riesling)。价格从 $14.99, £13 起。 在西澳大利亚葡萄酒 (Wines of...
Muscat of Spina in W Crete
Wines of the week 一款复杂的山地种植希腊麝香酒,挑战我们的期待。 起价 $33.99,£25.50。上图为克里特岛西部海拔约 800 米的斯皮纳麝香...
Greywacke's Clouston Vineyard, in Wairau Valley, New Zealand
Wines of the week 来自怀劳河谷 (Wairau Valley) 的典型新西兰长相思 (Sauvignon Blanc),如上图所示。售价17.99美元起,23...
Stéphane, José and Vanessa Ferreira of Quinta do Pôpa
Wines of the week 如果说有一个国家在性价比葡萄酒方面表现出色,那一定是葡萄牙。这又是一款支持这一理论的葡萄酒。价格从 7欧元,11.29美元, 20英镑起...

More from JancisRobinson.com

Ferran and JR at Barcelona Wine Week
Free for all 费兰 (Ferran) 和詹西斯 (Jancis) 试图用六杯酒来总结当今西班牙葡萄酒的精彩。本文的简化版本由金融时报 发表。...
Wine news in 5 21 Feb 2026 main image
Wine news in 5 另外:岭景酒庄 (Ridgeview) 被出售,威尔士提高酒类最低单价,四位新葡萄酒大师 (MW) 获得认证,朱利安·莱迪 (Julian...
Patrick Sullivan & Megan McLaren in Gippsland - Photo by Guy Lavoipierre
Tasting articles 这个澳大利亚凉爽气候产区终于实现了早期的承诺。上图为酿酒师帕特里克·沙利文 (Patrick Sullivan) 和梅根·麦克拉伦...
Institute of Masters of Wine logo
Free for all 祝贺最新一批葡萄酒大师,今日由葡萄酒大师学院宣布。 葡萄酒大师学院 (IMW) 今日宣布...
Richard Brendon_JR Collection glasses with differen-coloured wines in each glassAll Wine
Mission Blind Tasting 仅仅仔细观察就能帮助你弄清楚杯中是什么酒。 欢迎回到盲品任务!现在我们已经介绍了 盲品的各种方法,以及盲品所需的所有工具(见 必备工具)...
Erbamat grapes
Inside information 一个古老的品种,高酸度、低酒精度,可能有助于弗朗齐亚柯塔 (Franciacorta) 应对气候变化的影响。 去年九月,我受到贝卢奇...
De Villaine, Fenal and Brett-Smith
Tasting articles 一个极端年份,因令人瞠目结舌的筛选而变得稀有。上图为联合总监贝特朗·德·维兰 (Betrand de Villaine) 和佩琳·费纳尔...
Joseph Berkmann
Free for all 2026年2月17日 年长的读者对约瑟夫·伯克曼 (Joseph Berkmann) 这个名字会很熟悉。正如下面重新发布的简介所述...
Wine inspiration delivered directly to your inbox, weekly
Our weekly newsletter is free for all
By subscribing you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.