Volcanic Wine Awards | The Jancis Robinson Story

Torbreck's founder hits back

Monday 9 September 2013 • 3 min read
Image

Dave Powell (pictured), founder of the high-profile Barossa Valley winery Torbreck, and producer incidentally of this wine of the week, is a colourful character. Once met, rarely forgotten. When I last saw him in a smart London restaurant a couple of years ago it was difficult to prevent him from showing me a brand on his buttock that he had somehow acquired on a recent trip to Scandinavia.

The company had to be rescued financially 10 years ago and five years ago was taken over by the American owner of California winery Quivira. But Powell was still very much in evidence, particularly in Asia where he did much to put Torbreck and its relatively high prices on the map. Quite what he has been responsible for in the past few years is now hotly disputed but according to this recent article in Wine Spectator by California-based Harvey Steiman, he has been shown the door. No one would expect him to go quietly and here is his statement this morning:

I'm deeply distressed and saddened by the events that have unfolded at Torbreck over the past week. It was never my intention to leave Torbreck and to have lost the company, my hard work of 20 years, and my sons' inheritance is an absolute nightmare for me.

I was offered a deal five years ago when I had my back to the wall financially, which my lawyer told me not to sign. In extremis and under the illusion of goodwill I signed it anyway and that one stupid mistake has cost me my life's work.

The article in Wine Spectator this week stated that my management style was 'volatile'. I'm particularly hurt by that because I treat my team like family, always have, and I count a great many of them as personal friends, friendships which will survive long after this mess is forgotten.

The article also insinuated that I haven't been responsible for hands-on winemaking since 2006. That's just complete bullshit. I've been in the Barossa alongside the troops every single harvest since I founded Torbreck in 1994, and I take full personal responsibility for the quality of every wine with a Torbreck label on it. That's why I wanted to declassify the 2009 Laird this year, as I have done in the past with the 2007 Laird and the 2008 RunRig. Something happened in the particular barrel store where the wine is kept. For the first time in five years the volatile acidity in the wine had gone through the roof and [was] left unchecked. I took responsibility for it and we tried to remedy it, but it couldn't be done. I believe the 2009 wine is unsaleable at the high price we command for it. I was offered a 'job' after losing Torbreck, selling my own wine on commission. Even if I had contemplated acting as commission salesman for the company I built from nothing, that couldn't be profitable without a 2009 Laird.

I have been accused of playing the victim, of being dishonest, of being reckless with company money. If I'm a victim it's of my own stupidity in signing that deal in the first place and I'm the first to admit it. The rest though, I strenuously deny.

As a result of the last week's proceedings I am now facing bankruptcy, living in a house kindly given to me rent-free by friends, driving a borrowed car. I've found out who my friends are during this time and I'm deeply grateful to all of them.

My passion and life's work lies in the Barossa and I plan to rebuild a new venture here with my son Callum, who is currently studying winemaking in France with our great friends Erin and Jean-Louis Chave. They're just two of the hundreds of great friends I made during the Torbreck journey and I am grateful indeed for the people who remain in my life.

They can take the company I built but they can't take my passion. Torbreck's just a label now – the future holds better things.

Of course I have no way of knowing the truth of his wild allegations about 2009 Laird. The 2008 is currently on sale at over £500 a bottle.

 

Become a member to continue reading
会员
$135
/year
每年节省超过15%
适合葡萄酒爱好者
  • 存取 288,913 条葡萄酒点评 & 15,880 篇文章
  • 存取《牛津葡萄酒指南》《世界葡萄酒地图集》
核心会员
$249
/year
 
适合收藏家
  • 存取 288,913 条葡萄酒点评 & 15,880 篇文章
  • 存取《牛津葡萄酒指南》《世界葡萄酒地图集》
  • 提前 48 小时获取最新葡萄酒点评与文章
专业版
$299
/year
供个人葡萄酒专业人士使用
  • 存取 288,913 条葡萄酒点评 & 15,880 篇文章
  • 存取《牛津葡萄酒指南》《世界葡萄酒地图集》
  • 提前 48 小时获取最新葡萄酒点评与文章
  • 可将最多 25 条葡萄酒点评与评分 用于市场宣传(商业用途)
商务版
$399
/year
供葡萄酒行业企业使用
  • 存取 288,913 条葡萄酒点评 & 15,880 篇文章
  • 存取《牛津葡萄酒指南》《世界葡萄酒地图集》
  • 提前 48 小时获取最新葡萄酒点评与文章
  • 可将最多 250 条葡萄酒点评与评分 用于市场宣传(商业用途)
Pay with
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Join our newsletter

Get the latest from Jancis and her team of leading wine experts.

By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

More Free for all

J&B Burgundy tasting at the IOD in Jan 2026
Free for all What to make of this exceptional vintage after London’s Burgundy Week? Small, undoubtedly. And not exactly perfectly formed. A version...
Australian wine tanks and grapevines
Free for all 世界上充斥着无人问津的葡萄酒。本文的一个版本由金融时报 发表。上图为南澳大利亚的葡萄酒储罐群。 读到关于 当前威士忌过剩...
Meursault in the snow - Jon Wyand
Free for all 我们在这个充满挑战的年份中发布的所有内容。在 这里找到我们发布的所有葡萄酒评论。上图为博讷丘 (Côte de Beaune) 的默尔索...
View over vineyards of Madeira sea in background
Free for all 但是马德拉酒,这种伟大的加强酒之一,在这个非凡的大西洋岛屿上还能在旅游开发中存活多久?本文的一个版本由《金融时报》 发表。另见...

More from JancisRobinson.com

London Shell Co trio
Nick on restaurants A winning combination in North London beguiles Nick, who seems to have amused the trio behind it. Above, left to...
SA fires by David Gass and Wine News in 5 logo
Wine news in 5 Also: the WHO calls for raised alcohol taxes; more tariff drama; Champagne sales decline, and protests continue at Moët Hennessy...
Ryan Pass
Tasting articles Some promising representatives of the next generation of California wine brands. Above, w inemaker Ryan Pass of Pass Wines (photo...
The Marrone family, parents and three daughters
Wines of the week An incredibly refreshing Nebbiolo from a sustainably-minded family that sells for as little as €17.50, $24.94, £22.50. - - -...
Aerial view of various Asian ingredients
Inside information Part five of an eight-part series on how to pair wine with Asian flavours, adapted from Richard’s book. Click here...
Vineyards of Domaine Vaccelli on Corsica
Inside information Once on the fringes, Corsica has emerged as one of France’s most compelling wine regions. Paris-based writer Yasha Lysenko explores...
Les Halles de Narbonne
Tasting articles Ninety-nine wines showing the dazzling diversity of this often-underestimated region. Part 1 was published yesterday. See also Languedoc whites –...
September sunset Domaine de Montrose
Tasting articles Tam thinks so – and has nearly 200 red-wine recommendations to show for it. Come back tomorrow for the second...
Wine inspiration delivered directly to your inbox, weekly
Our weekly newsletter is free for all
By subscribing you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.